|
Search Term : Stone sour
DC++ Reults : 100 (no number given- guess)
Emule Results : 151
Frostwire Results : 321
Shareaza Results : 151
KCeasy Results : 313
Download - Stone Sour Through Glass
DC++ Results : Couldn't start download
Emule Results : 10-20 minutes @ 200B/s - 10kB/s
Frostwire Results : < 1 minute @ 120-140kB/s
Shareaza Results : < 1 minute @ 50-120 Kb/s
KCeasy Results : 1 minute + @ 5-50 kB/s
Network
Serch Cephalectomy, Woods of Ypres, Reservoir Dogs
DC++ Results : COULDN'T SEARCH!
Emule Results : Cephelectomy : 1 Woods of Ypres : 10 Reservoir Dogs : 308
Frostwire Results : Cephelectomy : 0 Woods of Ypres : 5 Reservoir Dogs : 191
Shareaza Results : Cephelectomy : 0 Woods of Ypres : 68 Reservoir Dogs : 282
KCeasy Results Cephelectomy : 122 (let my note that NONE with actually songs) Woods of Ypres : 144 (only 5 or 6 were actual songs) Reservoir Dogs : 348
Options
DC++ - Again, I have to open two ports for this software. And again, it was a hub based software, which I still really hate. Searches sucked. Speeds sucked. Joining hubs sucked. Stability of speeds in unknown because I couldn't get anything to work. When I was able to find a song to attempt, it refused to download. As for the help and options, they weren't good. The help pages were some of the most poorly written pieces I have ever seen. The options were many and poorly laid out making it more comfusing.
Verdict : Uninstall/Ports closed
Emule - There were a fair bit of options but it was simple to set up. Required port forward and hub connection which I'm not a fan off. As for speed, the stability of it was horrible. You connect to other users was unstable, slow and prone to disconnect.
Verdict : Uninstall/Ports closed
Frostwire - Using the latest version I was able to use it to get most of the files I looked for at great speeds. Couple this with Soulseek (Another p2p software I didn't review) and BT and you can get almost anything you want. Options where simple, and it was brain dead easy to set-up.
Verdict : Stays installed
Shareaza : This software is really a pity. It's a genisus piece of software but support and development have basically stopped on it leaving many many many bugs un fix. The best part of this software is the networks it spans and it's built in BT client. While it is a pretty powerful client I don't think it can stand against uTorrent.
Verdict : Watch carefully for further development
KCeasy : Don't even test this. Its so full of spyware, ads, and crap it's horrible. Its connects to the Ares network which is dieing from an overflow of spyware. While its seems to be a good piece of software, don't bother. It really isn't.
Verdict : Ban's webite/Uninstall
Overall - While DC++ Emule have massive networks and are ideal for university students I would still suggest they use Soulseek instead because of it's lack of hubs and effiecnt interface and build. As for those of us unlucky enough to live in the real world, I am going to have to say, Frostwire, the spin off of Limewire, is the most stable, spyware free and fastest of the lot I tested. If shareaza is ever to receive an update again, I will test it again but until then it's just too underdeveloped.
|